**Wile's Proof
of Fermat's Last Theorem **

James Constant

math@coolissues.com

Wiles says that, because the Frey/Ribet elliptical equation is non modular, his modularity theorem proves FLT. I say that the Frey/Ribet non modular eliptical equation disproves Wiles' modularity theorem. Wile's contention that the Frey/Ribet non modular eliptical equation and FLT do not exist is error, because the Frey/Ribet equation exists for Pythagoras' theorem and for the Arithmetic Rule of Addition. See details at http://www.coolissues.com/mathematics/Wile'sfalseproofsofMTandFLT.html

**Copyright
©
2008
James Constant**

**By
same author:
**